Wednesday, July 5, 2023
HomeeCommerce Marketing8 Steps For Larger Conversions

8 Steps For Larger Conversions


Amazon Listing Optimization: 8 Steps You Can’t Miss For Higher Conversions

What good is site visitors to your Amazon product itemizing if it doesn’t convert? The standard of the itemizing itself is what convinces prospects to make a purchase order after they land in your product web page.

However high quality is subjective. Some merchandise carry out higher than others. So, how are you going to be sure your product itemizing is changing finest? Amazon Itemizing Optimization. 

On this sensible step-by-step information, you’ll study:

What’s Itemizing Optimization on Amazon & Why Is it Essential?

Amazon itemizing optimization is the method of giving your Amazon product element web page a glow-up with the aim of accelerating your conversion charge.

A well-optimized itemizing communicates the product’s advantages clearly, overcomes objections, and persuades the client that the product is strictly what they’re in search of.

As a rule of thumb, a baseline conversion charge to purpose for is round 10-15%.

However it’s value noting conversion charges can fluctuate and depend upon components reminiscent of your area of interest’s competitors, your product class, and its value level, amongst different components.

By constantly optimizing your Amazon listings, your merchandise keep aggressive and interesting to prospects, resulting in elevated gross sales.

Associated studying: Be taught extra about Amazon search engine optimisation rating components and the nuances of Amazon Search Engine Optimization (search engine optimisation). Plus, discover ways to dominate natural search outcomes and conduct key phrase analysis.

What Do I Must Suppose About When Creating An Optimized Itemizing on Amazon?

To rank increased in Amazon search outcomes, it is advisable think about optimizing for related key phrases, utilizing high-quality photographs, and creating an optimized title and outline, to call a number of. We’ll go into extra step-by-step element quickly.

Additionally, do not forget that Amazon’s A9 algorithm considers not solely the optimization of your itemizing but additionally the general high quality of your product. 

Buyer notion and suggestions play a major position in driving gross sales. You could pay attention and regulate your product and repair to fulfill your prospects’ wants. We’ll contact on this later in step 6. 

The FlyWheel of Amazon Itemizing Optimization

Every element of the Optimization Flywheel mutually helps steady enchancment and progress in your Amazon itemizing, guaranteeing visibility and efficient conversion from looking to purchasing.

Amazon Listing optimization flywheel

Whereas not elaborately mentioned on this information, key phrase analysis is significant. With out site visitors, the optimization flywheel stalls. Thorough key phrase analysis optimizes your Amazon itemizing’s positioning for prime rankings and site visitors era in Amazon search outcomes.

Haven’t obtained your key phrases sorted?

We go into extra element about find out how to conduct key phrase analysis to find out probably the most priceless and related key phrases in your product to rank for in our Amazon search engine optimisation information. Earlier than we break down the sensible steps of Amazon itemizing optimization, right here is the canvas you get to work with.

The Anatomy of an Amazon Itemizing

The anatomy of an Amazon Listing

Essential itemizing components embody optimized:

  • Title
  • Product Ranking
  • Worth + Transport Data
  • Product Data
  • Picture choice
  • A+ Content material/Enhanced Model Content material (EBC)
  • Opinions 
  • Product Options

Now you understand what you’re working with, let’s get to work.

Step 1: Optimizing Your Amazon Product Itemizing Titles

Arguably, one of many first components Amazon’s search algorithm cares about is how related your title is to the client’s search question. Having an optimum title will increase your visibility and its Click on By means of Charge (CTR) on the outcomes web page. Whereas titles are technically for the algorithm, writing for people works higher. 

Listed here are two examples of properly optimized titles for “greens powder.”

amazon listing optimization title examples

Title Optimization Greatest Practices 👍

  • Character Depend: Ideally, maintain your title between 100-150 characters, prioritizing the primary 80 for optimum cell viewing. Regardless of Amazon’s 200-character restrict, titles shorter than 150 characters usually carry out higher.

An ECF Member who lately A/B examined a number of titles discovered  “shorter titles carried out higher IN GENERAL. It’s case particular, in fact.” 

  • Key phrase Optimization: Be sure the title’s first 5 key phrases are probably the most search-relevant. Make the most of instruments like MerchantWords Reverse ASIN Lookup to determine and experiment with opponents’ worthwhile key phrases in your titles. However don’t neglect to write down for people…

“Whereas key phrases within the title are vital, the #1 purpose for a title is for a human to learn it and discover relevance.”

  • Use of Delimiters:  After the primary 5 main key phrases (excluding fillers like “the” and “a”), use a touch (-) or pipes (|). This creates a keyword-rich canonical URL for Google to crawl, bettering search outcome visibility. Embrace different related Amazon key phrases after the delimiter.
  • Embrace Vital Data: Don’t neglect so as to add within the must-have particulars: issues like the colour, mannequin quantity, the sequence, and amount if it’s related. For those who promote multi-packs or bundles, name that out in your title (i.e. 5-pack).
  • Capitalization & Numerals: Capitalize the primary letter of every phrase in your product title. Use numbers as a substitute of phrases (20 as a substitute of twenty), however spell out measurements reminiscent of pound, ounce, and so on.
  • Model Identify in Title: Embrace your model identify within the product title, ideally not initially until it notably boosts Click on-By means of Charge (CTR). As your model good points recognition and generates branded searches, the significance of its inclusion within the title will increase.

“Titles truncate as brief as 74 characters on Amazon’s app. For a model the place it’s not going to extend CTR on the itemizing, I sometimes attempt to put it in direction of the tip of the title reasonably than lead with it.”

Greatest to Keep away from 👎

  • Extreme Capitalization: Keep away from capitalizing all phrases within the title.
  • Ampersand Utilization: As a substitute of utilizing (&) to maintain titles shorter, Amazon recommends spelling out the phrase “and.”
  • Promotion Phrases or Deceptive Guarantees: Keep away from utilizing false guarantees like “100% satisfaction assured” or “Free delivery worldwide.” 
  • Key phrase Stuffing: Keep away from overstuffing your title with too many key phrases, which might confuse and delay potential consumers.
  • ASCII Characters: Keep away from utilizing ASCII (American Commonplace Code for Data Interchange) characters like © in product titles. They will mess with readability, particularly in CSV format. Promoting non-public label? Put copyright data within the description as a substitute.

Step 2: Optimizing Your Product Descriptions For Conversions

You bought the press. The customer is in your product itemizing web page; how do you retain them there now? 

“When writing product descriptions, go for readability over cleverness. Easy phrases and easy sentences.”

Greatest Practices for Product Itemizing Descriptions

  • Craft your bullet factors as compelling promoting factors: They need to persuade a purchaser that the product’s options are helpful, outlining why and the way they want this product.
  • Design your itemizing to be extremely skimmable: Place crucial data upfront. This method permits prospects to rapidly perceive your product’s distinctive promoting factors.
  • Capitalize the primary phrase of every bullet level: This attracts consideration to the distinctive promoting propositions (USPs) of the product.
  • Preserve every bullet level concise but informative: This helps prospects rapidly skim by way of whereas gaining a very good understanding of the product.

Greatest to Keep away from 👎

  • Code in Product Particulars: Keep away from utilizing HTML, JavaScript, or different forms of code in your product element pages. The one exception is line breaks </br> within the description.

Instance of Product Itemizing Description Performed Effectively (& What May Be Improved)

Let’s have a look at an instance of the NutraChamps Inexperienced Powder instance we checked out earlier:

Amazon Listing Optimization Bullet Points Example

What they’ve achieved effectively: 

  • It’s descriptive and offers factual details about the product
  • They’ve highlighted the advantages of the product and described find out how to use the product in a scannable method
  • They’ve highlighted ache factors (i.e. not all the time straightforward getting combined greens into your food plan) and the way this product solves it
  • They haven’t stuffed it with key phrases 

What may very well be improved:

  • The bullet factors may very well be extra concise
  • Some components of the copy sound a bit an excessive amount of like advertising and marketing materials (i.e. Belief us, you’ll find it irresistible!) 
  • Phrase rely is over 300 phrases which is kind of prolonged. Attempt to maintain it beneath 200 phrases
  • They may need to think about capitalizing the phrases earlier than the primary sprint to make the bullet factors extra scannable (i.e. CLEAN & NATURAL BOOST) 

Bonus tip: Struggling to write down or edit your itemizing? Get AI help from Helium 10’s Itemizing Builder. Create sections of your whole itemizing utilizing your prioritized key phrases with a single click on. For those who’re a Helium 10 consumer, this function is available.

Step 3: Deciding on the Proper Product Photographs & Visuals for Your Amazon Itemizing

Selecting the suitable pictures and visuals when establishing your Amazon product itemizing generally is a game-changer in attracting prospects and driving gross sales. 

Deciding on & Optimizing The Proper Product Photographs 

  • Use the Full Quota of Photographs: Amazon permits as much as seven visuals, together with the principle photograph and video demonstrations. Use this to your benefit. 
The importance of your image selection for Amazon Listing Optimization
  • Present Totally different Views: Embrace pictures with totally different angles and makes use of of your product, together with close-ups. The aim is to reply buyer queries, selling higher product understanding visually.
  • Combine Video Content material: Movies showcasing your product’s features can improve purchaser understanding. Based on Amazon, including movies may probably improve gross sales by as much as 9.7%.
  • Leverage Picture Optimization Instruments: Make the most of companies like PickFu to optimize your product listings. By working a ballot, you utilize this suggestions to make extra data-informed choices about your picture choice.

“Our top-line income elevated by 10% when switching from the pictures we thought have been the perfect ones to those that Amazon prospects choose by way of PickFu.”

Going again to our greens powder instance:

Leverage Amazon’s A+ Content material For Most Conversions

A+ Content material is a function on Amazon to reinforce your product listings with wealthy story-telling media like high-quality pictures, charts, and movies.

Including A+ content material to product element pages may also help improve gross sales by a median of 5.6%. (Amazon Inside Information)

The principle aim of A+ Content material is to spice up gross sales by bettering conversion charges, growing model worth, and offering a extra immersive shopping for expertise. This may also help differentiate your product from opponents. 

Right here’s How you can Optimize A+ Content material Strategically To Enhance Conversions

  • Emphasize Distinctive Promoting Options: Use high-quality pictures in addition to some particulars about your product, notably if not beforehand included in your common product itemizing pictures. For e.g. zooming into particulars of your product and speaking extra in-depth about the advantages to your prospects.
  • Maximize Worth With Distinctive Modules Out there: Ship key messages in probably the most concise and visually-appealing manner. Put your self in your prospects’ footwear and take into consideration their fundamental questions. 
  • Prioritize Cell Optimization: With half of Amazon’s searches carried out on cell units, a mobile-friendly product itemizing is crucial. And on cell, your A+ Content material seems earlier than your customary bullet factors listing. 

Be aware: A+ content material can occupy quite a lot of house on cell screens. Evaluation your itemizing throughout units to make sure an optimum viewing expertise.

Within the desktop view video beneath, the A+ Content material follows the usual product itemizing. It incorporates a carousel detailing model factors, a founder’s be aware, and CTAs directing consumers to particular product classes. Picture banners beneath create a visually enriched product description, highlighting advantages.

Step 4: What do I would like to think about for Product Pricing Optimization?

Product pricing optimization must be an ongoing course of, notably with fluctuating components like seasonality and competitors. Due to this fact, this month’s profitable value might not be optimum for the subsequent.

“All the things I do know and realized about Amazon itemizing optimization results in the next conclusion: altering your pricing is probably the most highly effective take a look at of all.”— Andrew Browne, co-founder of Amazon cut up testing device Splitly.

Basic Worth Testing Ideas

Andrew Browne suggests utilizing Weber’s Legislation for value testing. This implies most of your potential prospects gained’t discover the incremental pricing changes. 

He recommends: 

  • Beginning with 10%, regulate by one other 10%, and maintain testing till you discover the optimum value.
  • If you improve the worth, be sure the potential drop in gross sales is offset by the elevated revenue per unit.
  • When reducing the worth, the lower in revenue per unit must be compensated by a major increase in gross sales.
  • Experiment with distinctive value factors. As a substitute of conventional pricing like $19.99 or $19.95, attempt one thing distinct like $19.87. 

“I’ve discovered it tough to check pricing as a result of competitor pricing jumps round a lot and can typically react instantly to any of your adjustments.”

Break up Testing Transport Costs: Actual-life Situations

One thing else you’ll be able to embody in your pricing A/B exams are delivery expenses. The consensus is that Amazon prospects are skilled to anticipate free delivery.

“Generally, gross sales DOUBLE if you provide FBA (free delivery and the Prime badge) vs. FBM with a +$X delivery.”

So what are you able to do? 

Bake delivery into your value and provide “free” delivery.

Amazon Listing Optimization Shipping Considerations

How some ECF members dealt with delivery prices of their companies:

One ECF member suggests two strategies for dealing with delivery prices:

  1. Incorporating delivery prices into the product value and offering free delivery for all orders (previous apply of theirs).
  2. Providing free delivery as soon as a buyer’s order exceeds a certain quantity (their present method).

He believes that the impression of charging for delivery on the conversion charge (CVR) is much less substantial for distinctive or scarce merchandise than frequent, widely-available merchandise. And he recommends utilizing a free delivery threshold to each reward prospects with a excessive lifetime worth (LTV) and increase the common order worth (AOV). 

This method didn’t negatively impression their CVR, which stayed between 2.75% and three.5%.

One other ECF member shares a method for dealing with delivery prices and instances in his former gift-focused enterprise, the place delivery instances have been essential. That they had even developed a customized date picker for patrons to know when their order would arrive and be charged the mandatory delivery charges.

The technique:

  1. Present three new delivery choices: In a single day, 2-day, and Specific.
  2. Provide free customary delivery for orders over $325-$350 and embody product upsells to encourage prospects to achieve this threshold.
  3. Enhance the readability of delivery time data on the product web page, cart, and checkout.
  4. Cross on the precise value (or barely extra) to prospects for categorical delivery.

This technique helped to transform delivery from a value to a revenue heart by integrating a portion of the bottom delivery value into their merchandise and charging barely extra for categorical supply than it value them. They discovered that prospects in pressing want are sometimes keen to pay extra, which might additionally assist enhance the conversion charge.

“ I agree that the only largest CRO enchancment you may make is to discover a strategy to make delivery “free.” (i.e. make delivery APPEAR free). Generally this isn’t potential due to MAP (minimal marketed value) agreements and so on. But when doable, sure, I feel its principally a slam dunk.” 

Step 5: Establishing The Greatest Copy For Your Product’s Key Options

This part is sometimes called ‘the bullet factors.’ And when you think about the aim of bullet factors is to assist inform a purchaser (in a highly-scannable method), the elevator pitch in your product.

Perception from a small-scale take a look at on the ECF discussion board revealed that bullet factors might be overwhelming in some Amazon product descriptions. 

“Customers needed to have a fast manner of figuring out what a bullet level is about as a substitute of getting to learn the entire thing or having a large wall of textual content thrown at them.”

Provided that buyers are taking a look at a number of listings— being concise and clear makes them extra prone to learn it.

Bullet Level Ideas: 

  • Make bullets brief, easy, and concise, and persist with the product’s most vital advantages. 
  • Concentrate on the factors the place your product stands out and put extra detailed data in the remainder of the product itemizing (i.e. A+ Content material).
  • Think about using CAPS or [brackets] to make headings and separate bullets higher visually.

For instance:

Let’s evaluate two product descriptions for a cocktail shaking set. Does one make you’re feeling overwhelmed?

Amazon Listing Optimization Comparing Bullet Points 1
Amazon Listing Optimization Comparing Bullet Points 2

Step 6: Producing Constructive Amazon Product Opinions (And Reversing Damaging Suggestions)

Constructive critiques improve conversion charges and affect search rankings. 

“It was much more tough to get it to rank effectively and to stay as a result of we couldn’t get any critiques to point out up till yesterday.” 

However after getting them…

“After we jumped from 4 stars to 4.5 stars on considered one of our merchandise, our conversion went up 50% and has held there. That’s proper…50%. Meaning 50% extra gross sales in a single day with out doing anything.”

Methods for Producing Constructive Opinions

Handwritten Notes

Embrace a handwritten be aware together with your contact particulars, encouraging prospects to achieve out with their suggestions.

“We examined handwritten playing cards previously, and so they have a evaluation charge of Sep 11%.” 

Think about using a machine to create handwritten playing cards to scale up your efforts. These usually are not “typed”. They’re written by a machine that holds a bodily pen.

Example of handwritten notes written by machine asking for reviews

Automated Publish-Buy Emails

Ship a sequence of emails to consumers after they make a purchase order. Make the communication customized and helpful, providing useful ideas and sources concerning the bought product.

“We ship an e-mail or a sequence of emails to all consumers. If the product is straightforward, we ship one e-mail a number of days after supply. We ship two emails if the product is extra complicated and requires some hand-holding and instruction.”

First E-mail Ideas:

  • Make your “thanks” message priceless. Don’t simply ship a generic be aware; add worth to it.
  • Embrace a number of fast ideas or solutions to incessantly requested questions concerning the product the client has simply bought.
  • For complicated or digital merchandise, present a hyperlink to a useful video, reminiscent of a YouTube tutorial for setup.
  • Inform the client concerning the upcoming follow-up e-mail, guaranteeing transparency and managing their expectations to stop annoyance.

Second E-mail Ideas:

  • Ship the second e-mail ~5 days after the primary one
  • Ask if the client is pleased with the product
  • Present two simple textual content hyperlinks— one resulting in the product evaluation web page for pleased prospects and the opposite directing dissatisfied prospects to a web page the place they’ll contact you.
  • Reiterate your availability to help them in the event that they didn’t have a 5-star expertise, additional emphasizing your dedication to buyer satisfaction.
  • Incentivize sincere suggestions (NOT paid critiques). An after-purchase e-mail thanking prospects for his or her buy and asking for an sincere evaluation, coupled with a small low cost on their subsequent buy, can go a great distance.

Make the most of Amazon’s Request a Evaluation Button

You might additionally use Amazon’s ‘Request a Evaluation’ button, accessible at an order stage in Vendor Central. However these emails are extra generic. 

The email you can send to request a review on Amazon

Pay Consideration To Your Packaging Expertise

A foul unboxing expertise can equal unfavorable critiques. This occurred to Elizabeth Mercer, the Proprietor and Founding father of Sleekform.com

In Episode 485 of the ECF podcast, Elizabeth talks about how they’d a bunch of 1-star critiques on Amazon as a result of folks have been pissed off by the meeting directions. They redesigned their packaging and unboxing expertise, and the 1-star critiques disappeared. Better of all, after paying the one-time price to revamp the packaging, their per-item value solely elevated by $0.07. A small value to pay to stop 1-star critiques.

How To Deal With Damaging Opinions

It’s irritating if you get a 1-star evaluation, particularly if you don’t deserve it. However monitoring and responding to critiques, good and unhealthy, must be a part of your customer support course of.

This ECF member shares particulars about how they approached receiving a bunch of 1-star critiques—and fully turned them round.

“I needed to see if I may reverse a few of these critiques, so I despatched conciliatory emails to all of those prospects providing a refund and a proof. A few of them already responded positively.”

Here’s what the revised evaluation mentioned (from 1 star to 4 stars):

Reversing negative reviews example on Amazon

Takeaway: Regardless of the client not being glad with the product, this member’s proactive method to customer support remodeled a possible 1-star rant right into a extra impartial “it’s not for me” sentiment. Though it resulted in a full refund, the worth of demonstrating their dedication to buyer satisfaction to potential prospects is value the associated fee.

Amazon prioritizes sales-generating clicks, bettering each buyer expertise and their fee. Monitor and improve your product’s conversion charge, learning competing merchandise to make sure your efficiency is at par or higher.

Based on Amazon’s information, launching a Sponsored Merchandise marketing campaign can present a median weekly raise of fifty% in ordered models within the first yr.

  1. Key phrases: Start with key phrases that align with buyer intent in your product kind. Begin with extremely related, detailed search phrases and run broad match modifiers (+) on them. 
  1. Justifying spend: When contemplating shutting off adverts, assess the impression of your advert spend on natural rankings and gross sales, and in your backside line. One ECF member discovered profitability elevated after slicing advert spend by 95%. Nonetheless, testing and optimization are additionally vital. 
  1. Testing: Experimenting with totally different advert metrics and funds changes may also help steadiness revenue progress with out undercutting natural gross sales.

One ECF member examined numerous advert metrics to optimize profitability. 

“We’ve had combined outcomes. It will depend on the merchandise and your aim. For one merchandise, we turned off PPC constantly for Friday-Saturday, our income went up, and our rank has stayed sturdy. In truth, final week we offered precisely one much less unit in these two days as we did the identical two-day span the week earlier than once we offered 110 models with PPC. An additional $850 in our pockets.”

Some ECF members take a long-term method, aiming for marketing campaign break-even to spice up natural rankings. This ECF member, who has an aggressive technique for Amazon PPC campaigns, emphasizes the significance of a long-term outlook. 

“Amazon PPC completely helps you rank for the key phrases you’re bidding on. I’ve examined this time and again.”

Sizzling tip: Arrange the Model Referral Bonus. You’ll get 10% again on any exterior site visitors you direct to Amazon. This will pay for a few of your site visitors.

Step 8: Monitoring and Adjusting Your Amazon Itemizing Optimization Technique (A/B testing)

Regardless of following the information’s optimization steps, conversion charge fluctuations are inevitable. So, steady enchancment requires A/B testing or cut up testing.

“We’ve seen drastic, like 2 -10% conversion charge enhancements from adjustments, notably to titles and fundamental pictures for our shoppers.” 

Break up testing or A/B testing on Amazon sometimes entails experimenting with adjustments to product content material, visuals, and pricing. 

It may be fairly a handbook course of. However if you happen to’re an Amazon Model Registered Vendor, use Amazon’s device: Handle Your Experiments. It permits you to create A/B exams for Titles, A+ Content material, Bullet factors, and Most important Photographs. 

The excellent news is that establishing an experiment is comparatively straightforward, and considered one of ECF specialists Joshua Rawe lays out the steps beneath:

Setting Up Your A/B Take a look at

Discover “Handle Experiments” within the menu beneath “Manufacturers”

Select your Experiment kind right here:

Screen Shot 2021-02-17 at 12.38.01 PM

And select the ASIN you want to take a look at right here:

Screen Shot 2021-02-17 at 12.38.52 PM

Defining Your Speculation

You’ll have so as to add a reputation in your experiment; go for one thing easy. 

Choose your length, 4 weeks is the minimal, and ten weeks is the utmost. 

Then, you want a transparent speculation to offer your outcomes that means and assist you to take motion.

For instance, “Including our model identify to the title will enhance conversions,” or “Decreasing title size from 250 characters to 100 will enhance conversions by decreasing noise,” or “Including XYZ key phrase will improve conversions”.

Screen Shot 2021-02-17 at 12.40.49 PM

Create your Model B (the speculation to be examined)

In case your speculation is: “Including our model identify to the title will enhance conversions,” then you definitely’ll need to create a Model B title that features the model identify.

For instance:

  • Model A (title at present in use): Garlic Press with Idiosyncratic Performance and Clean Deal with for All Your Garlic Wants
  • Model B (title to be examined): Kitchenaid Garlic Press with Idiosyncratic Performance and Clean Deal with for All Your Garlic Wants

Click on Schedule Experiment and a pair extra confirmations.

Amazon will now fluctuate the title in your itemizing between Model A and Model B over the interval of testing and supply conversion information on the outcomes. 

Then, if you need to interpret outcomes, try this video:

However keep in mind: A/B testing isn’t a magic treatment for underperforming listings. 

A profitable product element web page requires high-definition pictures, participating keyword-rich copy, A+ content material, a carousel video, a score of 4 stars or above, and over 100 critiques. Prioritize these features earlier than considering A/B testing.

Closing Ideas: Optimization Is A Journey, Not a Vacation spot

Optimization is a continuous course of, not an endpoint. You’ll encounter challenges like copycats of your Amazon listings and ever-evolving algorithm updates.

However, if you happen to observe the great steps offered on this information, you’ll be higher ready to enhance your itemizing’s conversion charge and distinguish your product amid Amazon’s aggressive market.

Positive, there’s no scarcity of Amazon assist guides and recommendation accessible on the market. However wouldn’t you reasonably deep, nuanced recommendation explaining what it takes to optimize your Amazon listings and see outcomes? 

You’ll discover it within the ECF group. You’ll be able to study extra concerning the group or apply to hitch immediately.

Courtney Goudswaard

Publish by Courtney Goudswaard

Courtney Goudswaard is a contract author for eCommerce and associated SaaS manufacturers. She approaches her craft in a journalistic setting, delivering evidence-backed, action-packed, and easy-to-understand content material that retains your readers hooked. Join along with her by way of www.scribblecontent.com or on Twitter @courtig

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments